2.26.2009

the staggering consequences of pride...

i was chatting earlier with some ladies in the nurse practitioner program here at the university... i had been aware for awhile that the np (nurse practioner) program gets you out the door and into the clinic in a third of the time with a little less than half of the debt, none of the liability and hooks you up with a union to boot. not too shabby. you take a small hit on your income, but if you are in it for money please get out because you are ruining the profession. so to all candidate md's interested in primary care on upto anesthesia, why why why do you want to be doctors? tell the truth - is it because of the md? those two letters come at a hefty cost. believe me, i'm stained thoroughly with this sin, i like the thought of being the final authority, of being an md, doing the sign off, stopping the buck etc... but truth be told, deep down in places i don't talk about, its power - i know myself and i know the world enough to know its true. will i actually be the only final authority? the answer is simply, no. even with my md i won't. because increasingly np's are taking over primary care and advancing on other specialties, e.g. - my physical to matriculate into med school was completed by an np.

it makes perfect sense why primary care residencies have dropped off precipitously and will continue to do so, who in their right mind would ever go into primary care with an md when you can do it with an np? four years med school plus three years residency plus a negative $200,000 versus 2.5 years of school no residency and 100K max tuition (fyi np students after attaining their nursing degree pay by credit, go ahead and ask a med student and see if they know that) the only thing that doesn't make sense is why anybody would be surprised by this.

i have observed:
1. first year med students get up later than anyone i have ever met, its atrocious. i see everybody in the house leave in the morning and at what time because i sit right by the front door to my dorm and study every morning starting at 6:30 a.m. where i meet the guard coming on shift and exchange pleasantries and wouldn't you know its the p.t. and nursing students who are normally out by 7:30? a small cadre of md students do the early run, but you can't convince me with the argument that we study late because i've been privy to one of these 1 am study sessions and it can be described by many words but definitely not efficient. plus everybody knows nmda and ampa upregulation (keys to long term potentiation) happens while sleeping - consolidate those memories (on a side note my seven and a half hours of sleep a night in tandem with my tenacious yet seasoned optimism is my proven method for devouring this curriculum)  
2. the cost of med school will easily surpass $200,000, easily. actually tuition alone is $195,000, can i get a troubled med student relief program? as ashamed as i am to admit this i'm almost happy that the government is spending like carter because it probably means carter era inflation, which will discount my exorbitant tuition retrospectively
3. everyone - by this i mean from dean down to fellow first year has indicated that the first year of med school is a wash and fourth year is a vacation - that is the truth, whether you want to hear it or not is up to you. med school should be 3 years and residents should get a raise by about 20%. how much would that cost? medicare pays the bulk of resident salaries - there are 2x10^5 residents in the US today, lets give everyone a 20K raise - total cost 4 billion - a miniscule fraction of the cost of the iraq war, tarp, obama stimulus, bush's stimulus (remember that one), and finally drum roll please... it would be roughly one one-thousandth of the total annual cost in health care in the US, remember health care spending is like 15% of gdp (13 trillion). yes, giving those tired overworked house officers and residents (that keep the hospital going too) across the country a flat 20K raise would be one one-thousandth of the annual spending. and do you know what i would do with it? pay back loans faster, its a joke, so don't worry i couldn't actually "use" it. unless of course we are in a carter ahem i mean obama hyper inflationary phase in which case i would use it to buy food.
4. gross curricular inadequacy (where is nutrition?, where is micro? parasitology? patho? not till second year, if it all, and only briefly, how do i master this in a three/four week block. why is it that n.p.'s do it first year? where is pharm? where is intro to the dealing with the business of pharm? why is there a summer break? we don't need it a summer break. life is to cozy.
5 pervasiveness haughtiness - i have had several conversations with fellow classmates who shall remain nameless that have indicated gross deficit in health economics awareness to the point where i wonder if basic accounting or health economics should be in the curriculum. 
6. the moral hazard of pass/fail system: before the md students here skewer me, i know many have fought and died to bring us this wonderful system, and i know it is the reason i am friends with my fellow classmates as opposed to foes - but the short truth is that its being abused. we all know the universal truth that you get what you pay for in life, and if something is given to you for free you will not respect it, with every right comes a responsibility yada yada, so i am witnessing academic slippage, "i can still pass with a 70", "do we have to know that?", "hey, i still passed" it goes on. the the nonclinical years of med school culminate in usmle step one -thus every nonclinical experience in the first two years should be geared towards that exam, here the tell us not to even worry about it until three months prior-  the slippery slope of the pass/fail system that was initally and mercifully designed to depressurize the hyper competitive type a neurotic, but the cost is apparent - we are losing respect for the material. most want to do well - and most are silent - but the ground beginning to shake.

recommendations
1. md's unionize, i don't care if its illegal - everybody knows justice is for sale in this country, so get the law passed somehow, everyone else in the healthcare sector with the exception of the hospital volunteer is unionized. there needs to be a consolidation in physician leadership and the ama is not cutting it.
2. med school needs to be three years only, the time wasted here in first year is unimaginable, the motivated, cost sensitive should not be punished for the maintenance of an archaic system. it saves money, and would expiditously advance our career.
3. med students wake up! we are losing ground on all fronts. our own self discipline is wanting. our rights are being impinged to greater and greater extent. 
4. residents get a raise and a thank you. i know old timer they didn't have it as bad as you, but guess what they have different problems in this age that are worse than anything you ever went up against - you hours may have been bad, you may have gotten screamed at on a daily basis by the attending - but you may never have practiced defensive medicine, paid outrageous malpractice, sued multiple times, worked for an hmo, were buried in paperwork, or buried in a quarter million dollar education debt. life today is harder because there are a lot more people, more drain on resources, less trust in the world (especially for md's), revolving door of daily appointments, cost of living increases outpacing wages for decades

but despite all that, i still think i got it so good, i love what i'm doing
haaha

1 comment:

Hilda said...

Nice blog.

I like this entry because it confirmed some of the things I've been suspecting. It's nice to know that for primary care an option such as NP or PA could be almost as good as the MD. I started MS1 with you guys but am on leave. Perhaps permanently. I've been thinking a LOT about the pride issue these past few months as it definitely had a hold on me.

I was only around for a few months, but you definitely stood out. I'm sure you're going to have a bright career as a physician. Best wishes to you in your studies.

And yes, Beethoven's 9th is sublime.